Not fit for purpose – do Russian clubs serve the greater good?

Russia SnowWhat is the purpose of a football club? What is the use of paying players to play football? What do we get for our investment? Generally it’s agreed that football clubs are there to act as a central gathering point for the community, to generate community spirit, creating a oneness lost from sitting in caves or yurts listening to tales around a blazing fire. Other “ideals” have been tacked on along the way. To increase the uptake of sports activity, to bring media coverage and visitors to the area, get kids interested in sports and fitness. Give local businesses an outlet to promote their services/products to a wider audience. Never is there the point of a need for profit, it’s all for the greater good. Though this idea of the greater good is closer to the Hot Fuzz version than some utopian Marxist goal. At least in the professional game.

In Canada over a decade ago the need for a social purpose, a communal greater good as the base of a football club, was drummed into me. The club I rejoined had suffered serious financial injury and the whole place was being rebuilt from bottom up. I carried it with me from that point forward and appreciated it most of all during two years work in Germany, where very often professional clubs do have the greater good at heart, offering a complete sports and culture lifestyle to their community, while also driving forward at the highest level. Almost without exception I have yet to see the greater good appear in any sports club, let alone football club, in Russia or the former USSR. Community and the greater good are obstacles to be overcome.

Over the last number of years I’ve had the pleasure of conversations with one of Ireland’s most respected football commentators and experts, and am delighted to call Damien Richardson a colleague and friend. His practicality and idealism melded well with the Russian football system, his opinions on best practice even more so. A couple of months back I related a “pitch” meeting with a potential client club. I worked with them before though now it was a new crew manning the lifeboat. In 2008 I’d secured a high annual five figure (dollars), multi-year sponsorship deal that was the highest in their history. It ran out December last and they tracked me down for more. At the first meeting I saw there was more at stake. The club, playing in the Second Division, had to put together a budget for the new season or lose their pro licence. With time running out we sat down and looked at cold hard figures. I wanted to get everything from this meeting to bring back to my partner Jonathan, an Aussie financial genius, enough raw material so that he could work the numbers and make the club attractive to a sponsor. Of all the people I’ve worked with, Jonathan is the first who can bring together finance and sports in a way that I understand – if I can understand it then anyone we deal with can too.

Two hours into the meeting I went outside the office for a think. Absolutely nothing made sense. The begging bowl was rattled to the local government, factory and even a wealthy individual who had paid for a special needs centre close to the club premises. The club were in control of two professional teams (playing in the second and third divisions) and more than 15 youth sides which formed their Youth Football School. The youth section was largely funded by subscriptions, team specific sponsors (usually the parent of a player) and the local Department of Education and Science. Some scraps were thrown down from the senior sides, though this was in the form of hiring speciality coaches whose first loyalty would be to the professional sides. Between running costs and wage budget, the professional section needed just more than US$800,000. They reckoned their marketing value was more than half of this, even producing a “bought” report from a marketing agency who, curiously, hadn’t been able to produce a sponsor.

In Canada, the Club President (a Northern Ireland born man with a genius for details) used to add up our income from scratch to see what budget he’d give me. I’ve always done the same since. So now, even filling the stadium, with all tickets at maximum price, with double the merchandise sold from the best year on record, with all concessions doubled and paid to the club, with winning the leagues and getting one match (somehow) on tv, short of selling players, we barely came to a quarter of the budget. On real figures, we were under $100,000. Yet they had already signed players and staff, knowing they’d run out of funds before the first snow of Autumn. Every other year they were in the same situation and knew that their budget would eventually be filled out by the local government and government run agencies, as well as a politically linked company who’d “look after them” for future considerations. They’d even cut salaries for players, or not pay a few of them. Anything to survive the season. And yet, and yet, what comes yet (to paraphrase the famous commentary from Eintracht Frankfurt’s Miracle of 1999).

The earnest faces around the table signalled a genuine interest in their efforts to get a proper sponsorship deal and keep the club afloat. We boiled down the initial amount to something far more palatable and were coming to an arrangement when the Marketing Director started up again about respect and their brand. So I asked her why would a sponsor get involved with them? What does the club do to serve its community? The 5-600 who turned up for home matches only contained a handful of visiting fans. The club played in the third tier and were unknown with only local media and those looking for a gambling fix interested in them. They’d virtually no feed up from their youth section, no female teams, no rapport with the community and ultimately not fit for purpose. They had no keep fit initiatives for the locals, no outreach programs, no foreign links and were not value for money. Heads nodded in agreement, the Marketing Director looked at her phone and left to take a call, she didn’t come back.

The chronic underdevelopment of club structures in Russia and former USSR countries can be attributed to entities which have sprouted from a self-entitled, hand out culture where personal responsibility ended when shoulders shrugged. The endemic corruption in society finds a hothouse home in football where recently two Premier League employees were sacked for reporting to the General Director that funds paid out for player agent services were far more than those they’d personally been party to and signed off on. Instead of rooting out the source of corruption, the GD axed the whistleblowers, the same GD who had previously suffered for stamping down on corruption within his former club. He’d never taken a wrong penny, though he was afraid to find out who was.

So back to the meat of the story, the little club who could not find a sponsor. I gave them a proposal and offer of help, that we’d get a sponsor and also help with getting something started for the club to bring to the table. Start small, local and grow. Make a club for the town to be proud of. Hands were shaken, hugs given and I walked to the train station knowing I’d never hear from them again. The club are still struggling from hand out to hand out and will play in the Second Division again. They never got a sponsor and the (ex-) Marketing Director sent me an sms last week to tell me that she wanted to meet for a chat when I’d time, it appears she was a victim of one of my suggestions – valuing staff and optimising work. Her (ex-) boyfriend, the Club President, didn’t seem to feel that her work or performance were worth persevering with. Until Russian clubs realise what a well run club can contribute to and receive from the community, Russia and the former USSR countries will continue to lurch from boom to bust and year to year, all the while the sport grows more distant from the people.

The Author

Alan Moore

Russian based sports journalist, commentator and consultant, working with major clubs including Hajduk Split, Eintracht Frankfurt, Lokomotiv and Spartak Moscow. Current host of Capital Sports 3.0, former international boxer and semi-professional footballer and commentated at the FIFA World Cup 2018 and 2019 Rugby World Cup.

One thought on “Not fit for purpose – do Russian clubs serve the greater good?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *