Neymar: Calm the hype – is he really as good as we think?

NeymarWhen it comes to footballing prodigies- perhaps none have matched the whirlwind of hype that has surrounded Brazilian golden boy Neymar.

The list of statistics is endless. 54 goals in only 102 appearances for his club side Santos, already 17 goals for the Brazilian National Side, a Copa Libertadores win, the South American Footballer of the Year Award for the past two years, and a Fifa “Puskas Award” for goal of the year to boot. And he’s only just turned 21.

Comparisons to the greatest that have graced that game have been hurled at the young Brazilian from all angles, with comparisons to ranging from Leo Messi, to George Best. There is also the small matter of the undisputed King of Football Pele (sorry Mr Blatter) saying personally that Neymar is currently the “best player in the world”- hailing him as a “more complete player than Messi”.

With this in mind then it is only natural that I was rather fascinated at the prospect of watching one of the (if not the) brightest beacons of the future of football do his business against England this past Wednesday. The only problem was that he failed to deliver the goods.

Neymar’s greatest contributions to the game were two misses, one inexplicable from the rebound after Joe Hart’s fantastic penalty save- the other somehow even more so, as Neymar slid in to balloon over from four yards out with the goal gaping.

This is not the first time that Neymar has failed to live up to his billing as star of the show. If we cast our minds back 7 or 8 months back to the Olympic Football- despite his three goals Neymar never took the tournament by the scruff of the neck as we were told he would do, and his flashes of brilliance were sporadic to say the least.

The growth and the status of the Sao Paulo born hitman was sky-rocketed since 2010. He is the World’s 13th most wealthy footballer and has been rated by SportsPro Magazine as the most marketable footballer out there today. He has been pinned up as the poster boy of Brazil’s home 2014 World Cup, and the name of Neymar is become a world-wide household name.

Neymar has become the centre of one of the most long drawn transfer battles out there today- and it looks like its a straight fight between Real Madrid and Barcelona to sign the £50million rated attacker. But the question is this: On what premise has Neymar become such a massive deal?

The answer is, I am not totally sure. Everyone will have seen the clips of the mohawked maverick slaloming his way through defences and dazzling unfortunate full backs in the Brazilian Premier League for Santos- but Neymar is still relatively fresh faced when it comes being tested a truly competitive level (with all due respect to the vastly improving Brazilian League). The highest status competition that Neymar has played in is the Copa America with Brazil- with no World Cup experience. How can teams pay £50million or more on a player that has never played in a really very prestigious and competitive league or competition?

On top of this whilst the stats speak for themselves- his performances are nevertheless sporadic in nature. His technical ball skill and electric pace or undeniable. His effectiveness on the game however, can sometimes come into question; all the  more since he has become a marked man by wary opposition defenders. The truth is that whenever I have seen Neymar play he seems to have the mentality of a 10 year old playing on a Sunday in the sense that as soon as things go against him- he can become quite petty.

I think my argument was summed up beautifully by the England game on Wednesday. Flashes of real skill- but his influence was scuppered by a very average England defence (it seems his tactic of cutting his noticeable mohawk didn’t make it any harder for defenders to track him down). In reaction to the game Joey Barton tweeted:

Neymar was playing against Cahill and Smalling, no disrespect to them but they are hardly Beckenbauer and Baresi….and he never got a kick. I refuse to believe the hype.

I don’t agree with Joey Barton on many things, but I think his assessment was honest and fair. Neymar is undoubtedly an incredibly talented young footballer- but then again wasn’t Robinho when he left Brazil? I think it is too early to classify Neymar as one of the worlds best- when he has not yet even been given a chance to play on the stage where he can be the worlds best.

I am not saying that Neymar will not become a world-class player- in fact I believe quite the opposite. But we need to be careful we do not paint the picture of something that’s not. Neymar is one hell of a player. But he is not one of the world’s best yet, regardless of his talent and potential, and I think it is high time that we stopped talking about him as though he is.

The Author

Josh Bland

Child of the Football Manager generation. Football writer for,, and Metro Sport amongst others.

6 thoughts on “Neymar: Calm the hype – is he really as good as we think?

  1. Firstly, Neymar has over 100 goals for Santos.
    Also, I wouldn’t put Brazil’s Copa America failure down to a 19-year-old Neymar and he has also won the Copa Libertadores (in which he was joint top scorer) – a highly testing tournament that involves games as high as 4,000m and travelling equivalent of London to Mumbai.

    I totally agree that he can’t be compared with Messi and Ronaldo yet and i think he needs a move to Europe to deal with defences that afford him less space. But having said that i don’t think he is that far off & with all due respect, anyone basing him on a couple of international games & youtube clips isn’t best placed to judge him.

    While Messi & Ronaldo play football better than anyone else, Neymar does completely new things you’ve never seen before & i think this holds a certain merit. A comparison with Georgie Best is more apt in my opinion

  2. Nice post Josh! Completely agree with you about Neymar, don’t see how anyone can compare him to Messi when he hasn’t constantly played against physical and tough defences. Personally, i think your link to Robinho will be quite accurate. Both of them were/ are successes in Brazil, but Robinho has never really set the world on light when he’s played in Europe. I think Neymar might struggle with the more physical nature of European football (even though the Brazillian league has a reputation of being quite physical), its nothing compared to European football.

    On his move to Europe, guillem balague has constantly been stating that a move to Barcelona is on the cards for this summer or next. I will wait for that with great anticipation.

  3. I think Neymar may suffer the speed of European football.
    I saw many times in the Brazilian league how he basically stops to run to face a defender, like it is a western duel.
    I think that he won’t be able to do something like this in any European league, let alone in the Champion’s League.

  4. My biggest problem with Neymar is that he gets way more hype than Mario Gotze even though Gotze is without QUESTION the better player. Gotze was arguably the best midfield playmaker in the entire Champions League this season with 3 goals and 6 assists AND Gotze led his team to the Champions League Final while Name-mar isn’t even playing in Europe and in fact Neymar didn’t even win the Brazil league or anything else this season. Gotze has won 2 Bundesliga titles, 1 German Cup, 1 U-20 Euro, The Golden Boy award for best young player in Europe AND now made a Champions League Final. If Gotze wins the Champions League, it will not even be debatable.

  5. I got to agree With josh. I have only seen neymar in Olympics and England friendly and he didnt do a whole lot to impress me. He may well become world class from playing European football but he is not near the finished article. Scoring goals in brazil is all good and well but brazilians are not known for their defending !!!! Going to barca is a smart move as playing with messi etc will school him but are barca the same team without pep. Remains to be seen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *