Independance Day: A British perspective on Major League Soccer

henry and cahillThe state of “soccer” in the United States has often been mocked and maligned by their superior European counterparts, however it has also long been regarded as one of the biggest sleeping giants in the game.

As eight Premier League clubs have jetted off to the States for their pre-season and the USNMT put in a sterling performance during this summer’s World Cup, I wonder whether the beautiful game is finally ready to take centre stage in America.

Over the past half-century, many of the biggest stars in the game have gone over there to “raise the game’s profile”. Originally, Messrs’ Beckenbauer, Pele, Cruyff, Eusebio and Best all attempted the gargantuan task of shifting some of the nation’s sporting limelight away from NFL et al in the NASL. To an extent they were very successful as the North American Soccer League (1968-1984) flourished in the late 1970’s creating global media attention, high attendances (a league average of 15,000 in 1979) and national interest in the sport.

However, a maelstrom of the depression in the 1980’s, over-expansion and mismanagement crippled the League and created a recipe for disaster. The franchise’s severe reliance on expensive, old imports and a dearth of North American talent only compounded this matter. Eventually, the league folded and the popularity of the sport receded.

The MLS, founded in 1993 ahead of the 1994 FIFA World Cup, seems to have learnt from its predecessors mistakes and is now one of the most successful leagues in America. Despite early losses and rumours of its premature demise, the MLS gained more and more prestige and popularity. David Beckham marked the resurgence of European veterans to American football when he arrived at LA Galaxy from Real Madrid in 2007 and as more and more ex-superstars joined, the more attention was devoted to the league both nationally and worldwide. A trade was established where young, exciting hopefuls from the league, such as Clint Dempsey were sold to European heavyweights, while individuals such as Thierry Henry, Robbie Keane and Tim Cahill became Designated Players in the league.

Now, with average attendances higher than both NBA and NHL and an ESPN poll finding Baseball equally popular with 12-17 year olds, soccer’s popularity is at an all-time high in the states and this has coincided with increase in quality and ability to attract top players. The MLS is starting to be recognised as a competitive, high quality league and in recent months Clint Dempsey returned to Seattle Seahawks for $6,500,000, while his Team USA compatriot Michael Bradley went back to Toronto from Serie A heavyweights AS Roma.

What is especially noteworthy about that move and also the expensive capture of Jermaine Defoe from Spurs is that they both had the capacity to continue at a so called “higher-level” as JD was still the Europa league top scorer at the time of purchase and Michael Bradley was in his prime at 26. In recent weeks both Frank Lampard and David Villa agreed to join the new franchise New York City, two individuals who have played and succeeded at the highest levels. The former Champions League winners will be able to impart priceless advice to the younger players and also attract a bigger following of the sport and the league in the city and worldwide. Furthermore, Brazilian former Ballon d’Or winner Kaka signed for another new franchise in Orlando City in an attempt to resurrect his stagnating career.

It was this talented and rapidly progressing league which formed the backbone of Jürgen Klinsmann’s US team which progressed to the Round of 16 in the World Cup, with 8 out 11 starters in their 2-2 draw with Portugal being MLS players. They were one of the surprise packages of the tournament along with a lot of CONCACAF nations beating strong Portugal and Ghana to the second qualification spot before a heroic and stubborn performance against a technically superior Belgium side eventually saw their elimination. It is a youthful side which is sure to only improve under the excellent eye of their German coach.

However, what truly marks the sign of change is the fact that exciting, young players who impressed during the tournament have remained in their domestic league and not accepted any of the offers from traditionally bigger more prestigious league. For example, the combative Sporting Kansas duo Matt Besler and Graham Zusi stayed put at the current Eastern Conference Champions.

In this recent spate of mid-season friendlies, the MLS contingent have acquitted themselves well on the whole. Sounders drew 3-3 in a thriller against a club with lots of US connections in Tottenham Hotspur, while the Lilywhites’ deadly rivals Arsenal were vanquished by ex-hero Thierry Henry and Ian Wright’s son Bradley Wright-Phillips’s New York Red Bulls 1-0. Bar Manchester United’s 7-0 mauling against LA Galaxy none of the Premier League sides have completely dominated or embarrassed their opponents. This shows that the games are not only an attempt to tap into an emerging and potentially lucrative American soccer market but a strong test for managers to pit their players against and judge any areas of weakness.

What struck me personally was the fervency in some of the support over there. The average attendance is 18,000 and at some clubs such as the Seattle Sounders you could be forgiven for thinking that the club was from Premier League or Bundesliga judging from the fans. There is a 44,000 strong average crowd, which is higher than all but six Premier League teams.

The trajectory of American soccer is sky high, who knows if they carry on like this they could rival some major European leagues soon. This isn’t just a fad, Americans are starting to get excited about the sport and is laying the groundwork for future generations as well.

This graveyard is turning into a fertile breeding ground and we could see more and more top players head over there, not just in the twilight of their careers. This is a dynasty set to last.

The Author

James Rodgers

I am a student in North London and Football fanatic. EPL and Bundesliga enthusiast and Spurs anorak.

6 thoughts on “Independance Day: A British perspective on Major League Soccer

  1. I dont think Dempsey is built to play for the Seattle Seahawks, maybe the Seattle Sounders though.

  2. One thing the article neglects but is worth noting is that MLS is becoming a solid destination for players all over the Americas. Yes, the Euro leaguers are usually the splashiest signings, but players Valeri, Morales, Morales, Chara, Saborio, and so on are indicative of MLS as a rising force in signing excellent players. A number of players on the Honduran and Costa Rican World Cup squads play in MLS as well. It makes me wonder, as an American fan, at what point my fellow fans will stop wondering how MLS can stack up to Europe and start thinking of the USA as an actual team from the Americas.

  3. MLS is no doubt on this rise, but there are some major weaknesses about American soccer that need to be fixed in order for me to say “MLS” could rival the European leagues one day. The major problem is the single entity, close soccer pyramid, Americanized system mess. There is a fear for me about the future of American soccer without Klinsmann. Klinsmann done a wonderful job looking at and growing the American talent pool on every level. The vision he put into American soccer is what helping American soccer as a whole grow. Before Klinsmann became a part of the USSF, no one cared about the majority of America’s largest talent pool. That large talent pool is in the lower divisions and in our colleges playing in the NCAA. Because our soccer pyramid is closed off, past coaches never really looked at what our lower division stars can do. We see the fight those players have in the Lamar Hunt US Open Cup, but it never lead to anything. MLS is only developing 7% of our players and holding back 93% to rot in the lower divisions without any future hope to work their way up. America is a large country with a large population. With soccer on the rise, one league will not be enough because that large development gap can and will grow larger by the year.

  4. In my opinion, there are two gargantuane problems with soccer in the US/Canada. The first is pay to play and development. If a talented player goes into the academy at a decent pro club in Europe, he is expected to get a fair shot at the first team, but in the US, this is not the case. If you join an MLS academy, you must go to college and then be drafted again in the MLS super draft, maybe not at all, and usually not the same team. To tryout for the junior Olympic team, youth players must pay $350 for the first round, and usually over $1000 for the second.
    The other huge problem is that there is no relegation/promotion. If you go on FIFA’s website, you will find that MLS is listed as the first division, NASL is listed as the second, and the USL as third. The problem is, all three of these leagues are seperate, except that MLS teams are hiring USL clubs so they don’t have to have academies. I will write a full article on this issue at, and make a YouTube video on my channel, +Conquistos FC. Thank you for taking the time to read this comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *