Champions League – Can United Stop Barca?

Ahead of Saturday’s eagerly anticipated 2011 Champions League final between Manchester United and Barcelona, Back Page Football’s Ger McCarthy looks at the massive challenge facing Sir Alex Ferguson’s side as they attempt to wrestle the trophy from the Catalan’s grasp.

Manchester United claimed a record breaking 19th Premier League title at the weekend to cement their status as the kingpins of British football. A topsy-turvy campaign eventually ended with the Old Trafford club hoisting the Premier League trophy in front of their delighted fans but attention now turns to Wembley on Saturday evening and the final of the Champions League.

Barcelona have also claimed their domestic league crown winning La Liga with four points to spare over bitter rivals Real Madrid in a season Lionel Messi walloped in 31 goals and David Villa 18. The Catalans have also had the luxury of resting key players for a longer period heading into Saturday night’s showdown at Wembley and remain the bookies favourites (evens at the time of writing) to claim Europe’s top footballing accolade.

So just what can Sir Alex Ferguson do to thwart the incessant attack of Villa, Pedro and Messi? Is it possible to blunt the midfield dynamism of Xavi, Iniesta and Busquets? How can United breach a well drilled defence which has improved as the season has progressed with Pique and Valdes outstanding for the Camp Nou club?

The case for United

Sir Alex Ferguson has overseen a magnificent defensive campaign in this year’s Champions League with United conceding a paltry four goals en route to qualifying for the final. Nemanja Vidic has been in imperious form at the heart of United’s back four with Rio Ferdinand fitting in perfectly alongside the club Captain despite suffering a recurrence of niggling injuries.

Irrespective of the back four performances the Indian summer being enjoyed by goalkeeper Edwin van der Sar should give United fans cause for optimism in the Dutchman’s final game for the Old Trafford club.

Van der Sar has produced a string of terrific displays to help United claim the domestic league title but his calming influence on the United back four is much more important. Gone are the days of the constantly bawling Peter Schmeichel to be replaced by a just as stern but calmer Van der Sar. The Dutch international’s ability to come and claim crosses and corners as well as being the obligatory decent ‘shot-stopper’ will be of the utmost importance facing a devastating Barcelona attack.

United can defeat Barcelona if they follow the blue-print created by Jose Mourinho when in charge of Inter Milan last season. Pressing high up the pitch and harassing the Barcelona midfield is the best place to prevent the source of the Catalan’s attacks from materialising. In the likes of Darren Fletcher, Nani and Ji-Sung Park United have the legs to do the job whilst also supporting the front two.

Settling on Wayne Rooney and Javier Hernandez as his starting Champions League forward-line is probably the most pivotal decision made by Sir Alex Ferguson this season. Rooney was out of form earlier in the year until being deployed in a deeper lying role behind the Mexican which sparked the England international back into life. Hernandez is simply the signing of the season.

The Mexican has contributed 20 goals and led the line superbly belying his young age. The swiftness of his finishes has matched the speed at which Hernandez has built up a rapport with fellow striker Rooney and United have benefitted hugely.

Having the luxury of being able to leave the Premier League’s joint-top scorer, Dimitar Berbatov, on the bench for much of their European campaign solidifies the immense talent and importance of Hernandez and Rooney’s partnership to United. The Old Trafford club will need both players at their peak to overcome the Barcelona challenge on Saturday evening.

The case against United

Pep Guardiola has overseen another tremendous season for Barcelona by claiming the La Liga title and keeping a resurgent Real Madrid at arm’s length including semi-final victory to setup Saturday’s Champions League showdown with Manchester United. History is on the Catalan’s side following their 2009 European Cup final win over United in Rome in which Lionel Messi scored the second and decisive goal in a 2-0 victory.

Messi has been in irresistible form in Europe this season, leading his side in goals and contributing hugely in the build-up play to the majority of Barca’s goals. The fact defences have doubled up on the diminutive Argentinean has allowed the likes of Pedro and David Villa to blossom in a deadly three pronged attack.

Barcelona are the settled side heading into Saturday’s decider with the first eleven virtually picking itself should all players be fit and ready. United have decisions to make about their midfield quartet with Carrick, Scholes, Giggs, Nani, Valencia, Fletcher and Ji-Sung Park battling it out for the four starting berths. The Catalans wrapped up their domestic title a few weeks before United claimed the Premier League suggesting Barca will certainly be the fresher side ahead of the Wembley showpiece.

The form of Xavi and Iniesta has proven a huge fillip to Guardiola’s side with high quality of Barcelona’s play emanating from the midfield duo.

The return of Eric Abidal to the Barca first team squad following surgery earlier in the campaign should not be underestimated. The French international came on as a substitute to an emotional welcome from the Camp Nou for the final minutes of Barcelona’s second leg semi final win over Real Madrid. The sight of Abidal being thrown in air by his team mates following that memorable win has given the Catalan’s an emotional boost heading into the Champions League final.

Much of the talk about Barcelona usually centres on the skill of Messi or the ‘Tiki-Taka’ style of football regularly produced by the Spanish Champions. Goalkeeper Victor Valdes rarely attracts such headlines but the goalkeeper’s form has been hugely impressive in Barca’s march to the final. The form of Real Madrid’s Iker Casillas is the only reason Valdes has failed to pick up multiple international caps and the Barca net-minder’s performance at Wembley will go a long way to deciding the outcome of the final.


The 2011 Wembley Champions League final has all the ingredients necessary for a classic encounter. Two attack minded teams, both squads bursting with world class talent and the perfect setting on the hallowed Wembley playing surface to produce a Champions League final to remember.

I fully expect a repeat of the 2009 decider between the sides in Rome with United putting in a decent performance and dominating possession for a time but I just cannot see the Premier League Champions usurping one of the best Barcelona teams ever produced. Spearheaded by the irrepressible Messi, Barcelona will win the 2011 Champions League trophy to complete an historic double, further cementing their status as the best club side on the planet.

Stat Attack

• If Manchester United triumph at Wembley it will be the third time they have won the European Cup without losing a match

• Barcelona are the top scorers in this season’s competition with a total of 27 goals scored heading into the decider at an average of 2.25 per game. Manchester United have netted 18 times at an average of 1.5 per game

• United’s Ryan Giggs and Barcelona’s Andreas Iniesta top the goal assists chart with 4 each ahead of this weekend’s final

• Lionel Messi is Barcelona’s top Champions League scorer with 11 and is also the most fouled player in this year’s tournament (30 times)

• Sir Alex Ferguson will become only the second British manager to win the European Cup / Champions League 3 times if United win no Saturday night. Liverpool’s Bob Paisley is the other manager.

Betting Blog

The Author

Ger McCarthy

Author of the book entitled 'Off Centre Circle'. Champions League correspondent for Back Page Football, contributor to the Hold The Back Page football podcast, also a contributor to the Irish Examiner Newspaper, SetantaSports Satellite TV Sports Network, NewsTalk National Radio station, Shoot! Magazine and Dangerhere websites.

9 thoughts on “Champions League – Can United Stop Barca?

  1. I dont think Fletcher should start myself. A midfield of Valencia, carrick, giggs and park is what should be used. valencia’s pace will stretch barca and having giggs in there allows carrick to set back. If fletcher starts, it puts the onus on carrick to create which he isnt best at this season. Giggs has better ball retention and Park will also be there to swap with him. Parks constant running and giggs probing is the key to the midfield IMO

    1. Thanks for the comments Mark but after the week Giggs has had I doubt his head is in the right place to be starting a CL final

      Fletcher’s fitness and lack of match practice is also a concern so I think the midfield 4 will be Park, Carrick, Valenica and Giggs with Rooney playing off Hernandez.

      Irrespective of whatever formation and selection Sir Alex Ferguson ultimately decides upon I cant see Barcelona losing.

      1. Giggs’ll be ok. If you look at his stats over the past few weeks, he’s actually outperformed himself from earlier in the year.

        I think barca will win myself, but it’ll be a lot closer that 09, i think it might go to ET.

        1. Giggs will and must start. The guy is experienced enough to deal with it and Fergie certainly wont drop him just in case he isnt up to it. You are right Fletcher isnot ready.

  2. Nice preview. However I have to disagre about your tactical analysis of Inter. They did not press Barce high up the pitch, in fact quite the opposite, they sat back and got men behind the ball. I do agree though that United should press Barce.

    I think the key is that Barce’s defence is not strong especially aerially, the reason they keep clean sheets is because they always have the ball (which is a pretty good way ofpreventing goals!) So i think that Uni8ted have a good chance as long as their key players dont bottle it. Also think they need to man-mark Messi, with probably Park following him literally everywhere he goes – but noone seems to agree with me on that :-)

    1. Why admire lnter’s defensive tactics against Barcelona when we all condemned Greece at Euro 004 for similar tactics, nullifying great attacking teams including Czech Republic and Portugal to win that tournament?

      1. I didnt condemn Greece in ’04. People talk about anti-football but what is the aim of the sport? It is to score more goals than the opposition. Fans pay money to go and watch their team, it is their choice. If they dont like the way they play they can stop watching, but i would bet yopu that the Greece fans were pretty happy in ’04 and the Inter fans in ’10… so i dont understand the critisim. The teams in question have no duty to satisfy anyone with attractive football, the onyl peoplethey have any duty to is their fans, and I didnt hear any complaints from Greece ro Inter fans.

        Should Inter have attacked and giot beaten? where is the sense in that? Should we not praise brilliant defending? Inter and Greece played to their stregths which is what any good team must do.

  3. enjoyed the preview. and i agree with thomas, bout the lack of strength in Barce’s defense, that’ll give Man the hole they need. Hope they win!

  4. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have put
    in writing this blog. I really hope to see the same high-grade content from you in
    the future as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my
    very own blog now ;)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *