Are MLS trying to kill the Cosmos?

CosmosFor those who didn’t know, New York Cosmos (who now ply their trade in the NASL) won the Soccer Bowl 1-0 against Atlanta Silverbacks last weekend in their inaugural season. The winner came thanks to a 78th minute strike from ex-Villarreal and Spanish International Marcos Senna.

The championship was the club’s first since its return to professional football after being dissolved back in 1985 in the previous NASL. It felt like old times as well with bottles of champagne to be found all around the dressing room, the Cosmos are stamping their authority – a fantastic start for the revived franchise.

On the same evening (November 9th) a report from Goal USA surfaced stating that MLS were looking to re-allocate one of the CONCACAF Champions league spots from the US Open Cup winner and allow the spot to instead be given to the runners-up of the Supporter’s Shield in time for the 2014-2015 season. It would hardly be a surprising move if MLS were looking to do so considering the Open Cup winners this year was D.C. United, who came rock bottom of the Supporter’s Shield race with 16 points, 10 points off Chivas USA in 18th. The format change would undoubtedly symbolise preferential treatment to those who succeed in the MLS regular-season rather than be rewarded with continental competition for going on a good cup run.

There is a major downside for implementing such a change though. The historic U.S. Open Cup, which has been in existence well beyond any major Soccer league in North America, would not only become virtually redundant, but the removal of the CONCACAF Champions League spot would prevent any possible opportunity for clubs in the lower tiers of the soccer pyramid to be able to participate in continental competition – further strengthening MLS’s hegemony in US Soccer while possibly pushing the thriving NASL/USL scene back into relative obscurity.

The New York Cosmos have only played three months of competitive soccer and have already secured their first championship. The ownership group of the Cosmos have not been shy in stating their large ambitions of becoming one of the greatest sides in US Soccer, whether that be as a franchise in MLS or not. Cosmos captain Marcos Senna is an MLS worthy talent, even at the age of 37, alongside a number of other players such as fellow Spaniard Ayoze and Venezuelan forward Diomar Diaz to name just a few who could easily slot into any Major League Soccer team.  Under the tutelage of Giovanni Saverese, the Cosmos look to become a dominant team in the NASL for many years to come.

Senna AyozeIt isn’t just on the pitch where the Cosmos have shown tangible signs of progressing. The NY based side have attract an average of 6,859 fans per home game which isn’t too bad considering their brief existence (already a comparable statistic to Chivas USA) while a large contingent of fans were seen at the Soccer Bowl with a vast majority storming the pitch in celebration after the match. There are definite signs of an evolving, passionate fan-base, but also have opened themselves up to further exposure with agreements  of a major sponsorship deal with Emirates Airlines and, impressively/very significantly, a national television sports deal with broadcaster One World Sports.

The Cosmos are also seeking permission for a new 25,000 all-seater stadium as part of a privately financed $400 million entertainment complex known as Elmont Town Crossings – the kind of stadium that some MLS teams could only dream of (D.C/New England fans would understand).  New York Cosmos are looking to be one of the best in the U.S and it’s looking good so far.

So what does the rise of the New York Cosmos have to do with the reallocation of a CONCACAF Champions League spot? Quite a lot. If the Cosmos continued their ascendency and kept winning titles, enticing high quality  players and bringing in more fans then who is to say that one day they could not be capable of winning a U.S. Open Cup? Particularly when looking at the MLS club’s second string line-ups which are commonplace in the competition. Removing the CONCACAF Champions league spot could potentially deprive the Cosmos for ever playing in continental competition which would undoubtedly have a negative impact on the ambitious NASL as well, who are fully known to not want to be seen as a feeder league to MLS but a genuine competitor.

There are no financial restrictions in the NASL, no salary cap which was one of the reasons for why the Cosmos were able to build such a strong team so quickly, nor is there a limit on international players NY Cosmos or any other NASL side are allowed to have. This has perhaps rattled the cage in MLS HQ (which ironically is in New York) who feels their position as the number one US professional Soccer league is being threatened. Imagine the face on MLS commissioner Don Garber if one day the Cosmos beat an MLS side in the CONCACAF Champions League final – or worse – if they won a Club World Cup. Furthermore, the potentially game changing announcement of a new NYCFC team to play in MLS in 2015 could have perhaps been an attempt by Garber and co. to detract interest from the Cosmos and for fans to look towards either the Red Bulls or the new franchise. The moves made by the management at Major League Soccer could have a detrimental effect on US Soccer as a whole but mostly on themselves.

Of course there is the fact that we don’t truly know if Major League Soccer is looking for the U.S. Open Cup to be stripped of its Champions League place. The decision would ultimately have to be made by the USSF who at the weekend shot down the rumours – but who really knows what is happening behind closed doors? Nevertheless, the Cosmos are clear in their long term intentions to become the best soccer team in USA, if MLS were to be able to get the space removed then CONCACAF may even allow them in via an alternative route.

The MLS-Cosmos feud may have just begun but certainly has the legs to go on for many years to come, both on and off the pitch.

The Author

James Kilpatrick

I'm an aspiring journalist with a passion for football, in particular MLS as it is a league like no other. My other regular contributions can be found at Soccer Wire. For any work enquiries feel free to e-mail me. Contact:

6 thoughts on “Are MLS trying to kill the Cosmos?

  1. Interesting would love to see them in the MLS but with the new Manchester City / Yankees team announced for the city that seems unlikely.

  2. 1. This rumor was debunked awhile back. The MLS Cup losers will no longer play in CCL. Instead, the point leaders in opposite conference of Shield winners het the spot. Open Cup slot is unchanged.

    2. “Is MLS Trying to Kill the Cosmos?” would be the correct grammer rather than “Are MLS…”

  3. So you write an entire article and at the end you admit that it has no basis whatsoever.

    And as Urgle notes above, this was a rumor from a couple months ago that USSF quickly rejected as groundless. Not that, again, facts are of any interest or anything.

    As for the Cosmos, your conjecture that a second division club can and/or will come to dominate American soccer is, simply, ridiculous.

    What is it about dredging up some old team name from 30 years ago, slapping a bunch of MLS rejects into similar uniforms and sending them out to play second (or third) rate competition makes you think this is somehow significant?

    Stick to writing about something you understand.

  4. Hi Bill, I’d like to address some of your comments.

    1) Never at any point did I imply that my argument had ‘no basis’. I am making the argument that there is a clear rivalry between MLS and the Cosmos and that if these rumors were to be true, which we cannot say are not unless you happened to be an official source who is aware of what is happening inside USSF, then this would be a contributing factor to what I believe is a feud between the two and not the sole basis (which you assume) for the tension between them.

    2) This rumour was not from a ‘couple of months ago’ as the original report which sparked the speculation came out on November 9th – 10 days ago. Your suggested ‘fact’, which you insinuate I am ignoring, is therefore wrong.

    3) The belief that the NY Cosmos can be a dominating force is not ‘ridiculous’ for the reasons I have already listed in my piece. If you read the article properly you would have seen that NASL strive to be more than a second division to MLS and that the lack of financial restrictions placed on an NASL side means there is serious potential of such a team competing with MLS’ finest. A tangible prospect perhaps but hey this is just my opinion…

    4) This is a hypothetical theory you have come up with and not me. The acceleration of the Cosmos’ development in just 3 months is what makes me believe they have a bright future, not for any reason because of their history from the ’70s and ’80s.

    5) I may be incorrect but I can only suspect that you would not have written your last derogatory comment if you were unaware of my age.

    Thanks for reading my article though!

  5. Somehow down the line, i see the NY Cosmos joining the MLS one of theses days. Who can object to have 3 MLS teams in Tri state. one in NJ, one in NYC and one in L.I. I don;t see why not. Of course, i only see that happening if the Cosmos new stadium is build and MLS worthy

  6. I grew up in Manhattan when there were three MLB teams, Giants, Dodgers and the Yankees. Two were across the Esst River at 161st and it was always exciteing.

    I’ve been following soccer since I started playing goalie at the age of fourteen in 1948. It will probably not happen in my lifetime, but there will come a time when MLS and NASL will approach parity and the
    quality of lower leagues will have substantially improved.

    Each generation of young players are better and there parents more knowledgable.

    USA soccer has a long way to go, but it is on the move.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *