How do you solve a problem like a Newco?

by Roddy Graham

14th February 2012. For many lovers out there, a day to celebrate how much you adore spending time with your significant other. For many Scottish football fans, though, this was the day that started a chain of events that are still to be resolved despite the new season being a mere four weeks away from beginning.

It was on Valentine’s Day this year that Rangers FC were plunged into administration after a court battle with HMRC over an unpaid PAYE and VAT bill since Craig Whyte, the disgraced former owner of the blue half of Glasgow, took over the club in May 2011. Since that day the terms Ticketus, Newco and Sevco have became as synonymous with the club as the names of Greig, Cooper and McCoist.

This week’s event saw both the SPL and the SFL meeting to decide where the new Rangers should start their new life. After weeks of discussions at boardroom and fan level, the SPL clubs overwhelmingly rejected the club from their league. After 122 years in the top flight of Scottish football, the Ibrox team have to face up to their future away from their lofty position.

Now if this was any other club, well except Celtic I suppose, the club would immediately apply for SFL entry and either be accepted into Division 3 or lose their place completely (much like Gretna back in 2008 when they were replaced by Annan Athletic). But this is not just any club we are talking about. Scottish football fans are told, often, that without Rangers in the league the game is dead. There would be reduced attendances, reduced sponsorship and, perhaps most crucially, a major reduction in television money.

To combat this, proposals have been made this week to parachute the newco into Scotland’s second tier, Divsion 1. The plans include a deal to broadcast Division 1 games on tv – presumably every Rangers away match as I can’t see too many people tuning in for Morton v Cowdenbeath – and a change to the system of relegation and promotion across all divisions. This proposal is basically a compromise between the SPL, SFA and the other major ‘S’ in Scottish football; SKY. This would allow them to broadcast Rangers games this season with the likelihood of the Old Firm (or would that be New Firm?) games returning in a years time – providing, of course, that Rangers win the league title next season. Perhaps not so easy as a host of first team regulars have left in the past couple of weeks and only 13 players returning for pre-season training last week.

One thing about the proposals that I, and most other fans do agree with, is the introduction of a pyramid system in the Scottish game. As it currently stands there is no pyramid system in Scottish football which means if you finish bottom of Division 3 nothing happens to you. No relegation. No worry over your future. Just start in the same league again next season. If one good thing comes of this disaster it would be a pyramid system being introduced to give the likes of Spartans and Cove Rangers a chance of playing at a higher level.

SFL clubs will be voting on where the new Rangers will be playing next week. The vote is very hard to predict as a number of clubs have stated that they feel they are being blackmailed into voting Rangers into Division 1 and being threatened themselves with administration or liquidation if they refuse to let the club into the second tier. Fans have played a huge part in removing the club from the SPL; applying pressure on their chairman to vote ‘no’ through letters, emails and thoughts through forums and social media outlets but it is now up to the 30 chairman of the SFL to decide the future of Scottish football. Let me be clear here, I am glad I am not having to make this vote! Vote yes to the Division 1 proposal  and they could alienate a number of fans who are yet to renew season ticket books. Vote no and send them to Division 3 and their club might not be around in 12 months time when the newco would likely be promoted to the Second Division if you believe what the SFA chiefs have spouted this week. A figure of £16 million has been banded around – this being the amount which would be wiped out the game if this situation arises.

If you ask the average fan in Scottish football they would say the Third Division is where the newco should start. If you ask the average Rangers fan they would say the 3rd Division is where the newco should start. If you even ask the Rangers manager Ally McCoist he would say the 3rd Division is where the newco should start. But football is not, sadly in my opinion, a business first and sport second and money talks. This Friday the 13th, when the SFL vote takes place, will be a horror show that will leave it’s scars on the game in Scotland for years to come. Division 1 or Division 3? The ramifications for either will be huge. The question of how to solve a problem like a Newco continues.

4 Responses

  1. Mick Atkinson says:

    Well written piece, one point you missed re newco going straight into sfl 1 is that when they get promotion after 1 season, they will enter the premier league having walked away from all their debt. This will leave them financially stronger then every other SPL team who have gone about things the correct way.
    Fair?

  2. Roddy Graham says:

    Thanks Mick.
    And undoubtedly so. Especially if they are parachuted into 1st Division without any sanctions on them (transfer ban, points deduction etc). One thing I would find strange would be this; what happens if they get into Division 1 but don’t end up getting promoted at the end of the season? Will Sky still leave their TV deal as predicted if they send them to 3rd Division? It could be difficult to get out that league with what is basically a reserve squad at best.

  3. Harrymon says:

    Ive always said that they will struggle to get out of whatever league they are put into.these clubs know how to scrap and fight for survival and the very unfamiliarity of the situation will overwhelm newco as they struggle to adapt to all that’s happened in the last six or seven months,crowds will dwindle,you will be able to hear a pun drop at ibrox on match day as the fans melt away as they did in the 80’s.it is no foregone conclusion that newco will emerge immediately from any lower duvision

  4. Good piece on a messy situation. I just wonder how prepared McCoist will be for Division 1 football. Up to now he would have been watching players of a greatly different standard to those who will be available to him now. It will take a completely different skill set to deal with these challenges. While I’m sure all at Rangers will be hoping they can replicate the achievements of Juventus after the Calciopoli scandal, it’s not like they have players of the class of Del Piero, Buffon and Nedved to call upon!
    I have great sympathy for the clubs who have to vote on this though. The dilemma they face is basically a no win situation for them. Sky seem determined to get the Old Firm duopoly back in place as soon as possible despite the complaints that it was killing Scottish football. If that doesn’t prove business interests are priority in football, I don’t know what would.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply