Given’s untimely fall from grace signals the end of an era

by Dylan O'Neill

It was, in the end, inevitable. His inferior performances at the European Championships clearly showcased Given’s slow demise as one of the world’s finest shot-stoppers. His spillage from Antonio Cassano’s tame effort that subsequently resulted in Italy’s first successful headed effort of Euro 2012, from Cassano, landed Irish fans, and Given, in disbelief. His shattered confidence was laid bare for all to see but it wasn’t the first time Given had made such a costing, high-profile error. 

In fact, he’d been the driving force behind several mistakes, both for nation and club, of which were scuppered due to it being a ‘one-off’. Mistakes duly repeated themselves, ‘one-off after ‘one-off’, all be it not in quick succession, which led to fans believing he was still in his prime. It was only at the European Championships that many came to the realisation that Given had surpassed his zenith and could no longer dine at the big kids table.

This retirement was a long time coming for the 36-year-old hailing from Sligo. As goalkeepers usually tend to outlast their outfield counterparts, Given, nicknamed “Lazarus” at Newcastle because of his powers of recovery, had fortunately outlived his stay in the Irish team, and the majority of Ireland’s World Cup squad, providing memorable moments a plenty to leave the turf with and hang up his boots in the knowledge that he gave all he could for Ireland. For a man who plied his trade in between the sticks for over 16 years on an international stage, he merited more recognition than a mere two revered international tournaments – although one as his performance levels dropped considerably. As the FAI appointed some men just out of pure desperation on a reasonably shoe-string priced budget – primarily Steven Staunton, a man who was starved of any previous managerial experience – Given, and indeed the rest of the squad, were made to suffer at the hands of the FAI’s ahenanigans. When they finally did hire a man suitable of guiding the nation to qualification, Shay had already entered his final years as a seasoned professional and by that stage it was too late for his talent to truly shine.

There were, as I said, previous signs of his fall from grace. Whilst in the midst of a gripping qualifying campaign for the EURO’s late last year, Given was culpable for Armenia’s goal at the Aviva Stadium in Ireland’s final group fixture and also, at the same venue, for an Estonian goal that denied an Irish victory – both goals which would have never materialised had it been Given three, maybe four, years ago. There was another moment, albeit for his club side, Aston Villa, when Norwich striker, Anthony Pilkington, lined up a free-kick on the edge of the box. With the five-man wall covering the right of Given’s goal, and noticing his international teammate slowly inching towards the right, Pilkington fired the ball past a helpless Given and the area where he should have been covering. (In my opinion, and taking into account Given’s movement to anticipate a curling effort – and the speed of the ball – that free-kick should have never eluded him. Although that might just be me. Decide for yourself here.)

Many were grateful for Given’s willingness to stay on, despite Ireland’s recent shortcomings. He was there from the very start, making his hotly anticipated début, while plying his trade in the midlands with due to be crowned champions Blackburn – although unable to oust the then current England number one  Tim Flowers – and was thrown in the deep end for Russia’s visit in 1996. Mick McCarthy, experimenting with an unfamiliar 3-5-2, had been recently appointed by the FAI to succeed the legendary Jack Charlton and had handed Given his first international cap, as a reward for a string of impressive showings for Sunderland as they stormed to promotion with the 19-year-old in between the sticks. He soon nailed down a place in the national side, with thanks to Packie Bonner’s retirement, and has retained it ever since, despite the emergence of fellow international ‘keepers Dean Kiely, Paddy Kenny and Kieren Westwood, to name a few.

But, recently, his performances haven’t matched the public’s expectations and have lacked the cutting edge that the Irish were used to. He’s seen as the country’s saviour, the one they can rely on when the chips are down, the man who makes the impossible look a great deal easier. Sure, he may be susceptible to the odd lapse - Dion Dublin ring any bells? – but, in the end, he’s the man who – along with stalwart Richard Dunne – played a predominant role in how the Irish defence – 11 clean sheets in 14 games prior to the Euros – is they way it is, moulded under the tutelage of the wily Giovanni Trapattoni. In a system often referred to as the “Green Cantenaccio”, because of Trapattoni’s insistence on defensive solidarity, Ireland have prospered hugely and Given has played his part to near-perfection. During Euro 2012 Spain’s Xabi Alonso spoke, and in an eloquent manner, about the ‘system’ which teams, club or international, choose to endorse. While he was obviously referring to Spain and their respective style of play, he claimed that “the issue is not the system, but how you use the system”, and with Trapattoni his style of football, while it may be branded ‘boring’ and ‘unadventurous’, has reaped the benefits for Ireland and Given, at the base of the system, has been an integral part of it.

Author Info

Dylan O'Neill

Dylan O'Neill

Hi. I'm Dylan. I'm 17 and I enjoy watching and playing football and dabbling in statistics, predominantly football, among other things. I began writing about football in December 2010 and have continued to do so throughout my years in school, pitching in articles whenever I can. Websites that I've featured on include In Bed With Maradona, World Soccer, Spanishfootball.info, EPL Talk, Bundesliga Talk, Ghost Goal, the (recently deceased) Equaliser, and here on Back Page Football, where I do most of my work.

This entry was posted by is filed under Featured, International, Opinion and Tags: , . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

4 Responses

  1. David says:

    Shay Given is from Donegal

  2. Gerry says:

    Also he has never played international football with Anthony Pilkington

  3. Mark says:

    Shay has been a colossus for Ireland for 16 years and has decided to retire from the international scene with grace. I have nothing but respect for the man and the professionalism he has exuded during his career.

    The Euros were far from his finest moment but remember that he was carrying a knock into the tournament. I can’t think of a keeper in the world who would have shined given the insipid Irish performances in Poland.

    I’m an Aston Villa fan and am very happy to have Shay between the sticks.

    Keep on writing, David, but you need to do a much better job fact checking, as pointed out by the other comments.

    1. Mark says:

      Meant to say Dylan, not David. I need to do better fact checking on my comments!

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply