Al Volo: Bundesliga Overtakes Serie A, But For How Long?

This past week UEFA announced that starting in 2012 the top three teams in the Bundesliga will gain automatic entry into the Group Stage of the Champions League while the fourth place team will be eligible to compete in the playoff stages, potentially advancing into the latter stages of the competition from there. The fifth and sixth place teams in the Bundesliga will then compete in the Europa League.

The Bundesliga’s gain comes at the expense of Serie A as Germany has leapfrogged Italy in the much maligned UEFA coefficient ranking system. In previous seasons Italy has had three teams automatically entered into the competition but starting next year they will only have just two with the third place team entering the playoffs.

In recent seasons the German Bundesliga has become one of European footballs most popular leagues. Its forward thinking ideas, focus on native youth and the overall style of play has seen people begin to watch it more and more. There is no denying it is Europe’s most progressive league in many respects and the success of a young and vibrant national team at the recent World Cup has also helped attract attention.

Yet Serie A, for all the talk of its decline, is probably the healthiest it has been in seven or eight years right now. The effects of the Calciopoli scandal were far more wide ranging and damaging than simply the relegation of Juventus and looking at the teams in European competition since the subsequent punishments took effect highlights this fact. Excluding the usual ‘big four’, Chievo, Lazio and a newly promoted and severely weakened Juventus have represented Serie A in the Champions league over the four seasons directly after 2006.

The problem of the Europa League being influential in allocating Champions League places has played a major role and Livorno, Parma, Empoli and Udinese have taken part in the secondary competition over this same period. Clearly some very poorly equipped teams have been able to gain entry into European competition when the following season would see each of them much more likely to be in a relegation battle than a title fight.

Indeed it is this unbalanced system that has enabled the Bundesliga to overtake Serie A, as their teams have done much better in the secondary competition while so many teams from Italy have dismissed the competition and have been cheaply eliminated. Perhaps seven teams in Europe regularly is something neither league can sustain?

If the Bundesliga were to have had the extra places over that same five year period then teams like Hertha, Hamburg and Leverkusen would have been competing in the Champions League, while Hoffenheim and Bochum would have taken part in the UEFA Cup.

Clearly, while the German league has made huge strides this diluting of quality would have affected it severely. Indeed during the period illustrated only a single team (Bayern Munich in reaching last years final) made it past the Quarter Final stage of the Champions League, while Serie A has had two different winners.

Perhaps it is telling that this season, when finally being caught, Serie A is enjoying one of the closest title races anywhere in Europe but one which looks like ultimately allowing Napoli and perhaps even Lazio into the Champions League. While both squads have done well, they may lose a number of influential players ahead of their entry into the top competition, much as Sampdoria have done since last terms fourth place finish.

It is also easy to cast aspersions on the standard of Italian football in light of the most recent European results as Milan, Inter and Roma have all lost their most recent Champions League ties, yet other than the Nerazzurri’s opponents Bayern, Germany have only Schalke (currently 1-1 with Valencia) still in the competition after Werder Bremen finished bottom of their group, putting both leagues on very much equal same footing.

The Europa League results have also only been marginally better as only Leverkusen remain from the entrants of either country. While these eliminations already make poor reading the new allocation of places would mean that only Roma, Inter and Milan would have been in the top competition whilst Napoli and Juventus would not have been involved at all. Contrast that to Germany where Leverkusen would be a Champions League team and Hamburg would be in the Europa League.

A recent addition of a five point bonus for reaching the last sixteen of the Champions League could also aid Italy’s clubs as this is something they have – albeit with more teams – done consistently better than the Bundesliga clubs. Due to UEFA’s system a country loses points for every loss, and a diluting of the quality in each competition will arguably hurt Germany’s cause whilst a lack of entrants will strengthen the results of Serie A. This is not to say one league is stronger than the other, more a recognition that neither has the depth to support seven clubs in European competition.

One major contributing factor to this seeming instability is the sheer volume of teams winning places in the Champions League. England – who top the rankings table – have sent the same four teams into Europe’s top competition every season since 2003-04 with only Tottenham breaking into that group last season. Even in 2005 when Everton took fourth place Liverpool entered as holders while their cross-city rivals were eliminated in the qualifying stage.

If German clubs maintain their serious approach to the Europa League then they may hold their advantage in the coefficient. However, should the riches on offer for being part of the top four distract them as it has Serie A’s midtable clubs then while the Bundesliga may have the advantage of the extra place, how long remains to be seen.

Author Details

Adam Digby

'Al Volo' Serie A columnist on BPF, and Italian football journalist, contributor and Calcio Italia magazine. Co-founder of

6 thoughts on “Al Volo: Bundesliga Overtakes Serie A, But For How Long?

  1. The bonus points will make it easier for the Bundesliga to defend their 4th CL spot IMO.

    You seem to think that Serie A will continue to have 3 teams in the CL k.o. stages. But once Italy has only has 3 CL spots they will be happy to get 3 teams into the group stages.

    The Italian league will miss out on money and it could have a destabilizing effect on top teams in Italy. In Germany, on the other hand, the 4th CL spot will bring extra money and lead IMO to stability at the top.

  2. Yes I agree with Frank since the Bundesliga teams took advantage when the Europa League (ridiculously) offered as many co-efficient points as the CL. Now it is a little harder for Serie A teams to do the same.

    Bizzarely finishing 3rd in the CL group stages was and still is often better co-efficient wise, than finishing 1st or 2nd if the other team gets knocked out straight away. Even with the 5 point bonus coming in, Fiorentina were still “worse” than Liverpool in Europe last season, despite knocking them out!

    But I guess as far as UEFA are concerned there have to be some incentives to winning the EL. Sevilla have certainly profited from easier CL groups due to their huge co-efficient from their two UC wins, tho that obviously wasn’t much use when they messed up their play-off.

    Anyway the best hope for Serie A is that the Bundesliga continues to be as unpredictable as this season. The likes of Hannover, Mainz or Freiburg are probably not gonna do much in Europe, and as they have no experience would face a decent side in CL play-offs if they finished 4th.
    Of course Bayern will probably finish fourth and ruin that, so it’s best that Serie A just focuses on sorting itself out.

    So realistically, given that it’s measured over five years, and German teams will now have scored higher the past 4 seasons, it’ll be another four years at best before it turns around. However if a “big 4” type situation develops in Germany, it could be a lot longer, and it might be La Liga that Serie A needs to compete with…

    1. Agreed. That ‘Big Four’ point is the key. If Bundesliga remains unpredicable & Serie A’s top three remains stable then regaining the place is possible, otherwise as you say, the German league will more likely overtake Spain than fall back into 4th place. Thank you both for reading & taking time to comment.

  3. i think the difference will be in how seriously the italian teams take the EL.

    the two milan teams will almost always be in CL, and advance to the rd of 16. the third will be hit and miss, especially until roma gets sorted out.

    hard to see that changing b/c the battle for 4-10 is so tight that these teams can’t fight on two fronts. we’ll see.

  4. Bundesliga SUCKS. I hate the league. They are FUCKING overrated. Just because they do well in the secondary league (Europa league) doesn’t mean they are better. They do poorer in Serie A in the Champions League. What a problem Fifa should fix.

  5. Hallo Liebe,

    Ich bin auf Google suchen und finden Ihre Website. Es scheint gut zu sein für den Austausch von Links, wie Sie in der heutigen Welt compitative jeder will wissen, vorne zu bleiben. Das gleiche gilt auch hier. Wenn wir Links tauschen es beficial für uns beide. Wenn Sie vereinbart werden freundlich antworten mir.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *